patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

What Would You Put in Place of Talbots?

The sizable space at 217 North Ave. West is vacant. What would you like to see there?

 

Westfield, let's pretend you're at the drawing board and all ideas are on the table. In a modern take on town planning, each week we'll present a new vacant building and ask you to tell us what you think would be the best use of the space.

Forget what zone it's in, ignore setback regulations, dump lot coverage rules and all the other zoning jargon that puts people most to sleep.

If you had your way, what would you like to see there? What would be the best use for the community?

In our first installment, let's look at the space that was previously occupied by Talbots, located at 217 North Ave. W. We've all seen the lonely spot and thought to ourselves, "I'd love it if somebody opened..." (This is where we need you to fill in the blank.)

So vote in our poll and tell us why you chose what you did in the comments.

  • What would you put in Talbots place?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • A clothing store
        82 (31%)
    • A pet shop
        11 (4%)
    • A salon
        0 (0%)
    • A restaurant
        29 (11%)
    • A brew pub
        109 (41%)
    • A children's gym
        6 (2%)
    • Other
        24 (9%)
    Total votes: 261
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!

lois Pinkin

7:35 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

J. McLaughlin.....Clothing...Or J. Crew....Vineyard Vines...

Reply

Victoria Stephens Williams

8:09 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Perhaps a branch of Cape May's the Lobster House or another beachy seafood restaurant.

Reply

harry

9:34 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

J. Crew??!! Another mall type retailer? why? So you won't have to drive to the mall at Short hills? Or shop on-line? Here is a novel idea, how about a family run business that might be around for a couple of generations that provides a useful service so we won't have to go to a big box retailer. Maybe someone with some taste and actually knows it's customers and stands behinds their product or service. No that makes too much sense, we are only here until the kids get out of high school anyway so what do we care.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Patricia Hale

8:11 am on Friday, January 27, 2012

That's the Westfield that I grew up in. All of the stores were family businesses. My parents owned Auster's at 143 E. Broad St. They provided superior service and attention to their customers. Ultimately, big box stores were able to sell merchandise for less than my parents were paying wholesale from their suppliers.

I'm glad the downtown is thriving still, yet the Mom and Pop stores that populated the downtown when I was growing up, made Westfield a cozier, friendlier place.

ANS

9:48 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Ron nice idea and I agree completely, but... the rents that these building owners charge make that quite prohibitive for many individuals wanting to run a business in Westfield. So sad.

Reply

Megan

10:40 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

it is a pretty big store, but i'd love to see a LUSH open up in Westfield. for those of you who do not know, LUSH is a cosmetics and bath store. all their products are handmade using fresh organic fruits and vegetables, using ONLY vegetarian ingredients and there is NO animal testing done. here's to hoping a LUSH opens somewhere nearby and soon.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kelley Schultz

11:22 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

No we have enough cosmetics stores in town

John Loconsolo

10:45 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Honestly though, A nice brewpub would a be a good fit downtown that serves delicious craft brewed beers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kelley Schultz

11:23 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Yesssssssssssssssssssssssssss please - a Brew Pub with hand crafted beers and nice selection of wines and drinks and some good pub food (not graesy grimey stuff!).

John Loconsolo

10:47 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

What Westfield really needs is a pizzeria.

Reply

harry

11:08 am on Thursday, January 26, 2012

mcdonalds, bk, kfc, another subway we only have 2, dunkin donuts we need another,
wendys, a coffee shop that can pull a decent shot, tgif fridays, applebees, legal seafood, brooks brothers, the limited, anthropologie, godiva, channel. That's it!!! Channel!!! we can all brag about that, imagine what the real estate sales people would say!! the sales pitches!!

Reply

Dan Lizmi

12:08 pm on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Why don't we work something up to get the stores that were burned out back in business. Been here over 25 years and Westfield certainly had a mom and pop feel.
Now we throw out the old and replace with even more national chains. Not saying its feasable, but at least give it a shot if the landlord is agreeable not to charge 500,000 per month

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Liz Mitchell Worthington

12:30 pm on Thursday, January 26, 2012

This is a great comment, Dan! I know Sherry Cronin has been working hard to help these businesses and I'm sure they are always looking for ways to bring them back. Please keep us posted here at Patch of any ways you or the community works together to help the businesses Westfield lost in the fire. We want to continue to highlight all the good work people are doing to help out in such a time of need.

Laura Busch

8:10 pm on Thursday, January 26, 2012

I am voting for a Ann Taylor Loft, I love that store!

Reply

A.John Blake

8:15 pm on Thursday, January 26, 2012

Anything other than another restaurant,pizza seller,frozen yogurt maker or any chain store presently in any mall around us.
A.John Blake

Reply

harry

9:22 am on Friday, January 27, 2012

Thank you Patricia Hale!!! My family relocated here from brooklyn, ny just about the time when woolworths was closing. In the 15 years we have lived here westfield has been turned into an outdoor shopping mall. Believe it or not brooklyn was and is far more mom and pop than westfield. The services are better because they have a vested interest in the neighborhood rather than a store like Talbots that didn't make it's sales numbers and decides it is not worth it to stay. But ANS makes a very valid point with the high rents and ability to compete reduces the chances of survival for a mom and pop operation. Other towns didn't take the path that westfield has taken(i.e. tarrytown, ny) and has managed to have almost exclusively mom and pop businesses. I guess it speaks to the communities inherent values and what the community wants. westfield has an attractive downtown, it is too bad that it's usefulness for someone like myself that does not use the majority of the stores because I can shop on line without risking a parking ticket. Remove all the streets and put it all indoors already and be done with it.

Reply

ddougyy

11:51 am on Friday, January 27, 2012

A good micro brewery/brew pub would be successful in Westfield. Not sure if that location is the best, but we still need one. Those sorts of things typically seem to do best when they have their own building upon which to create their own, unique identity.

Reply

Corinne

11:52 am on Saturday, January 28, 2012

I think Talbots should never have left. Bring BACK TALBOTS!!!!

Reply

Linda

5:34 pm on Monday, January 30, 2012

The demographics in this town are just aching for J. Crew!

Reply

John Loconsolo

7:51 pm on Monday, January 30, 2012

Because J. Crew is so much different than Banana Republic. Is it that much of an inconvenience to drive to one of the multiple nearby malls to buy J. Crew? How about something completely different. I said it once, Westfield needs a classy brewpub that crafts its own beers that serves really good pub and tavern food. Here are a few examples: Vermont Pub & Brewery: http://www.vermontbrewery.com/, Merchant House Tavern: http://www.merchanthousetavern.com/, Light Horse Tavern: http://lighthorsetavern.com/, Triumph Brewing Company http://www.triumphbrewing.com/princeton/, Taphouse Grille: http://www.taphousenj.com/

Reply

harry

12:01 pm on Tuesday, January 31, 2012

yes, I agree, the best way to experience westfield is at least partially inebriated.

Reply

John Loconsolo

12:49 pm on Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Craft beer is not about getting inebriated. People that drink beer to get drunk can stick to any of the major label swill that is out there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

harry

9:05 am on Wednesday, February 1, 2012

I am giving up the ghost on this one. I did not mean to offend you in anyway JL, in fact I think it is a good suggestion. The links you provided, while I have never been to those establishments,(I don't drink that much) strike me as fitting to the direction westfield has taken in the past decade or so. I guess I am in the minority, so it seems by the posts, that my preference would be to have a smaller, vested business, preferably family run, that might be around for a couple of generations. A craft brew pub certainly is something that westfield does not have presently and is a far better addition than another mexican restaurant. I don't know about you, but one craft brewed beer or ale certainly takes the edge off and I wouldn't drive home after one.
Cheers!

Ted

2:21 pm on Tuesday, January 31, 2012

while it's fun to talk about what we'd like to see in that location, it would be great to see properties like that (and certain ones along South Ave near train station) redeveloped for mixed use, with retail on ground floor and office/residential on second and maybe third floors. this would add valuable foot traffic, boost ratables, improve the town's look -- esp. along south ave. -- and promote economic development.

Reply

John Loconsolo

9:40 am on Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Ron, no offense taken. Truth be told, I have not lived in Westfield for about 8 years at this point, but my parents still live there. Since I only live about 30 min north and work in nearby Linden, I do come to town often. So it would be nice to see Westfield get a nice brewpub to go out to when I do come visit my parents or get together with friends who still live in the area. I really think that the bank building on the corner of North Avenue and Elm Street (across from State Farm) would have been a perfect location for a brew pub type of place.

Reply

harry

11:08 am on Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Yes, JL, the bank would be perfect for a really great brew pub, I completely agree. It is mystifying to me how some properties in westfield(and others towns too), like the bank on elm and broad and the bank on north and elm(about 10 years it stood vacant until it was divided up), stay vacant for so long. It certainly detracts from the downtown to see such landmark type buildings stay empty year after year. The bank on elm and broad could be a showcase rather than eyesore. I don't pretend to know the economics of it all, but it certainly would be nice if the owners of the vacant building might open it up to the community to display art produced by our area school children or some other beneficial endeavor while waiting for tenant to rent the space.

Reply

Leave a comment